Bella’s Signature Sandwiches

All Sandwiches are served on your choice of Homemade Bread or  Wrap

and served with the “Salad Creation of the Day” 

~  Everything is made fresh to order, thus ensuring the most enjoyable dining experience. 

Please allow adequate time to prepare your meal.  If you’re in a hurry Isabella suggests PB&J!

 V -Eggcellent Eggsalad $6

Classic Egg Salad with Lettuce and Tomato

The Frontenac $8

White Chicken Salad with Chopped Celery, Lettuce and Tomato

Muskie Surprise $8

Surprise - It’s Tuna (Solid White) with Chopped Celery, Lettuce and Tomato

V- The Grindstone Grilled Cheese $6

Provolone, American, Mozzarella, and Tomato Slices Grilled to Perfection!!

Tibbetts Point Turkey $9

Oven Roasted Turkey, Feta Cheese, Tomato and Bella’s Garlic Mayo

Wyanoke Boathouse $8

Grilled Breast of Chicken, Melted Provolone, Lettuce and

Tomato with Bella’s Garlic Mayo

Round Island Raspberry Chicken $8

Grilled Breast of Chicken, Sweet Vidalia Onions, Served with a

Raspberry Sauce and Melted Provolone Cheese

The Calumet $9

Black Forest Ham, Swiss Cheese, Spicy Mustard, Sweet Onions,

Lettuce and Tomato

V - The Zipper $8

Red and Green Peppers, Vidalia Onions, Tomatoes, Mixed Greens and Provolone Cheese Served with Bella’s Hummus or Basil Pesto

Loonie Turkey Reuben $8

Oven Roasted Turkey, Sauerkraut, Thousand Islands Dressing and

Swiss Cheese Served Open-Faced on Rye

The Murray Isle $9

Roast Beef, Creamy Horseradish Sauce, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce and Tomato

Smoked Curried Chicken Salad $9

Smoked Curried Chicken Salad with Dried Cherries with Organic Field Greens

Tom Thumb Tuna Melt $9

Tunafish (Solid White) with Served Open-Faced w/ Sliced Tomato & Melted Swiss

Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap $8

Sliced Grilled Breast of Chicken, Crispy Romaine, Bella’s Garlic Croutons, Shaved Parmesan and Caesar Dressing all wrapped up!

Salads and Paninis

All Paninis are served on your choice of Homemade Bread or a Wrap, unless otherwise stated, and are served with the “Salad Creation of the Day” 

Bella’s Cafe Cubano $9

Pork Tenderloin, Black Forest Ham, Swiss Cheese,

Spicy Mustard and Pickle Slices

 V - Pine Island Portobella- $9

Portobella Mushrooms, Roasted Red Peppers, Vidalia Onions, Fresh Baby Spinach, Feta Cheese and Basil Pesto Grilled in a Wrap

Resort Island Roast Beef Panini- $9

Roast Beef, Vidalia Onions, Swiss Cheese with a

 Creamy Horseradish Sauce

Halfmoon Bay Ham Panini- $9

Black Forest Ham, Apple Slices, Honey Mustard and Swiss Cheese

Bluff Island Beef and Blue $9

Simple - Roast Beef and Blue Cheese

Asian Chicken Salad- $10

Grilled Breast of Chicken Served over a Bed of Romaine

tossed with Chow Mein Noodles, Cashews & Peppers with a

Spicy yet Cool Cusabi Dressing and a Croissant

Picnic Point Spinach Salad- $10

Fresh Baby Spinach, Bacon, Vidalia Onions, Almonds, Egg,

Shredded Carrots, and Provolone served with an

In-House Sweet Poppy Dressing and a Croissant

Excelsior Shoal Caesar Salad $10

Grilled Breast of Chicken, Homemade Croutons and Shaved Parmesan Cheese Served on a Bed of Crispy Romaine topped with a delicious Caesar Dressing and Served with a Croissant

Jug Island Julienne Salad $10

Oven Roasted Turkey, Black Forest Ham, Provolone Cheese, Peppers, Homemade Croutons, Onions and Tomatoes Served on a bed of Crispy Romaine topped with a Tangy Greek Dressing  with a Croissant

V - Grenadier Greek Salad $10

Peppers, Onions, Tomatoes, Feta and Kalmata Olives tossed with Romaine Homemade Croutons and a Tangy Greek Dressing  with a Croissant

**Add a Grilled Breast of Chicken for $2

Richardson Island Salad $9

Generous Scoop of Bella’s Chicken Salad, Tunafish, or Curried Chicken Salad served on a Bed of Mixed Greens Garnished with Shredded Carrots, Tomato, and Cucumbers (No Bread No Croutons)

*To Make Any of the Salads or Paninis Gluten Free, be sure to

Request no Croutons and  ask your server for Gluten Free Bread

Our Mayonnaise and MOST of our Dressings are Gluten Free